Attention: You are using an outdated browser, device or you do not have the latest version of JavaScript downloaded and so this website may not work as expected. Please download the latest software or switch device to avoid further issues.

News > Events > OWBA > OWBA Phoenix Society Debate: 2016

OWBA Phoenix Society Debate: 2016

The Phoenix Society is deeply ingrained in West Buckland history and has been  for over a century.

20 Feb 2017

Over the decades there have been some quirky and rather pertinent  topics for discussion including:
·         “The Court of the Grand Phoenix hereby charge the Rolling Stones with wilfully corrupting modern youth."
·         “One should be patriotic to Europe rather than to Britain”
·         “ The British attitudes to refugees is deplorable”
·         “America should never have been discovered”
Today it is a thriving debating group and a Phoenix Society Tie is still a most coveted possession among  sixth formers.
The inaugural OWBA V WBS Phoenix Society debate and dinner in the Karslake Hall proved to be an evening of lively topical discussion.
“This house would neither retain nor replace the Trident nuclear deterrent” (OWBA opposing)
Last year’s Phoenix Society President, Sam Davies (09-16F) and Vice President of the OWBA Col Ian Blewett (72-77G) were most vociferous in their arguments to keep Trident and pupils Rudi Small (current President) and Matt Gentle were equally impassioned about disposing of the deterrent.
Questions and comments from the floor were challenging, insightful and entertaining.
Motion won by the opposition, speeches by the proposition.
It was a superb evening and special thanks goes to Mr Jonathan  Ralph for his live Twitter feed.
Phoenix fact 1 –
Romance blossomed between Rachel Kilburn (80-82F) and Rob Withecombe (73-82F) at their first debate with the Phoenix Society many years ago when they were on opposite sides on 'corporal punishment is unjustified' Rachel won the debate but Rob won her heart and they later married.

Photo gallery

To view this photo gallery

Similar stories

Tom Hitchins Lunch: 2016

West Buckland School was the venue for The Tom Hitchins’ lunch in November. More...

Holly Meredith
Remembrance Day 2020

Today we honour the staff and pupils of West Buckland School who sacrificed their lives for their Country during conflic… More...

Tom Hitchins Lunch 2019

A jolly time was had by all who joined us for this year's Tom Hitchins Lunch, held at Yelverton Golf Club. More...

Most read

Christmas is not what it used to be

Everybody at this time is beset by uncertainty and concern. It seemed therefore a good idea to try and ease the burden of this with a little dose o… More...

14 year old Jack's Diary 8th May 1945
VE Day Memories - Jack Leslau (42-49F)

We were recently asked by David Cummins (40-50G) if any of his cohort recalled what occured at WBS on VE Day 1945. Our thanks to James Leslau for his … More...

Jonathan & Bob
Visitors to WBS: Jonathan Edwards

Jonathan Edwards (76-84G) pays us a visit.. More...

Have your say

This website is powered by